Time to Send EE Back to AAA?

by Chris Murdico 4/16/2008 4:36:00 PM

*Disclaimer: This blog post is coming a little late because of some technical difficulties with the site, but I still wanted to get it up and express my thoughts and opinions.* 

This past weekend in Pittsburgh the Reds returned to what fans here in Cincinnati hoped they were finally moving passed. They showed that they are, at least at this point, the same old Reds that can't get runners in when in scoring position. While this was a team epidemic this past weekend, there was one player that stood out above the rest, and not in a good way. That player would be starting third baseman, Edwin Encarnacion. Not only has EE been hurting any fantasy teams that chose to draft him to play their corner infield position or utility spot, he's been killing his real life team every time he steps up to the plate lately.

In the series against the Pirates, Encarnacion stepped up to the plate four times, yes four times, with the bases loaded. So how did he do? He went 0-for-4 and didn't drive in a single run. At the end of Sunday, Encarnacion's batting average had plummeted to .179 (7-for-39). Aside from the one game in the first week against the Milwaukee Brewers where he hit a walk-off homerun, he hasn't done much of anything that warrants him keeping his starting job right now. So what to do with the man on the hot seat playing the hot corner?

Unfortunately it might be a good time to send Encarnacion down to AAA Louisville so he can get his head on straight and get his mind right. Not only is he hurting the team as far as not being able to hit with runners in scoring position, not that he's the only one, but he's making it hard for Adam Dunn to see good pitches. Pitchers know that they can pitch around Dunn because Encarnacion is batting behind him and if they can't get Dunn out, EE will either get himself out or not come up with a hit to advance the runner. In order to get his game back to where most think it should and can be, a trip to Louisville in the early going might not be a bad idea. In his place the Reds could get more speed in the lineup and put Ryan Freel at third. He may not be the prototypical third baseman, but he's good defensively, something else that Encarnacion still has trouble with from time to time. And you can't move Jeff Keppinger over to third right now with Alex Gonzalez not returning to the lineup anytime soon.

Putting Freel in the everyday lineup would also allow CF Corey Patterson to move to the #2 spot in the lineup or maybe even down to the #6 spot behind Dunn to give him some protection when the Reds are facing right-handed pitching. Patterson, aside from Brandon Phillips, is the best hitter in the lineup right now, leading the team in homeruns right now. Moving him out of the leadoff spot might be a good idea right now if at all possible. If a move is made Dunn could even be considered as an option at the #2 spot in the lineup against right-handers. Dusty Baker should consider all his options before this weeks' important series against division rivals, the Chicago Cubs and the second go-round with the Brewers.

Sending Encarnacion down could be the first step in the right direction for this team right now. He has a ton of talent if he could just get his head into the game, or in this case, maybe he needs to think less and just go up focused and ready. It may feel a little too early to do anything drastic, but its better for Baker to do this now so he can get Encarnacion back producing at the level he's capable of sooner rather than later. While Encarnacion's psyche might take a hit, it will help him in the long run. If Baker is as smart as most think he is, he'll make this move now.

Related posts

Comments

4/16/2008 5:00:28 PM

Jim Humbert

I agree that Encarnacion is hurting this team much more than he is helping it. You did not even mention his horrific play in the field. Not only does he have four errors already, he has made numerous other bad throws and decisions.

Send him packing.

Jim Humbert us

4/16/2008 10:42:44 PM

Jimmy Dinsmore

I will take a differing opinion. In my opinion, one of the biggest problems is the left handed hitting combined with the batting order that Dusty has trotted out. Dunn is as big of a liability as EE. At least EE is right handed. But the team's real problem is their leadoff hitter has a miserable on-base percentage and is left handed. Their #2 hitter is their best hitter and on base guy. Their #3 hitter is left handed and so non-chalant now he's hurting the team. Phillips at #4 is a good hitter, but is trying now to be a HR hitter, probably because he's in the cleanup spot. Then Dunn (miserable), then EE (just as miserable) then a first baseman (both left handed and miserable) then a catcher (miserable). So you have two reasonably good hitters and then a bunch of fence swinging chuckers (to quote Keith Hernandez from Seinfeld).
I would try this lineup:
Keppinger
Dunn
Phillips
Griffey
EE
Patterson
Votto
Bako/Valentin

But, I would also get either Andy Phillips or Jolbert Cabrera up here from AAA. Don't know who you send packing, but bring those utility guys up who are right handed, then give EE and/or the first basemen a break.

Jimmy Dinsmore

4/16/2008 10:44:03 PM

Jimmy Dinsmore

and Freel is not an everyday player. I assure you if the Reds could find someone to take his salary for a bag of donuts, they would do it. Freel is a glorified Chris Stynes. Seriously break down his numbers, what does he bring to the table? NOT the answer, at all.

Jimmy Dinsmore

Add comment


(Will show your Gravatar icon)  

  Country flag

[b][/b] - [i][/i] - [u][/u]- [quote][/quote]



Live preview

12/4/2008 4:09:10 PM

Powered by BlogEngine.NET 1.3.0.0
Theme by Mads Kristensen

About the author

Name of author Author name
Something about me and what I do.

E-mail me Send mail

Calendar

<<  December 2008  >>
MoTuWeThFrSaSu
24252627282930
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930311234

View posts in large calendar

Recent posts

Recent comments

Tags

Disclaimer

The opinions expressed herein are my own personal opinions and do not represent my employer's view in anyway.

© Copyright 2008

Sign in