Watching Al Davis' press conference when he announced that he had fired Lane Kiffin (over the phone mind you) and had him escorted out by security got me thinking. Who's the worst owner in the NFL? It has to come down to Al Davis or Mike Brown. So, let's compare the pros and cons of both guys.
Football knowledge: Al Davis has been involved in football forever. He was commissioner of the AFL and head coach of the LA Chargers in the AFL. The guy knows football. Mike Brown's father (Paul Brown) was one of the innovators of the sport and a true legend. Nobody can deny his dad's knowledge and legacy. But Mike is not a chip off the old block. Mike has proven not to know football, or at least the modern NFL, like his dad. Since his dad's passing, the Bengals have floundered, without a GM, and having only 1 playoff appearance. Advantage: Al Davis
Success: This one heavily favors Al Davis. Under Davis' ownership and leadership (he's functioned mostly without a GM and makes most decisions himself) the Raiders have won 13 division championships, three Super Bowls (XI, XV, & XVIII) and made 15 playoff appearances. Mike Brown, as mentioned, has guided the Bengals to one division championship and one playoff appearance (a loss). Advantage: Al Davis
Drive/Commitment to winning: The Raiders motto is Commitment to Excellence. They've shown that commitment in year's past with big money acquisitions and big player moves. The Bengals, under Mike Brown, seem content to field a "competitive" team. The Raiders have a significant amount of scouts and personnel talent. The Bengals have a guy and a rental car. Al Davis fires coaches and makes bizarre moves under the flag of trying to win. Mike Brown rarely talks of winning and has done nothing to show fans or the city that he truly cares about winning. Advantage: Al Davis.
Honor/Ethics: Finally a category Mike Brown can dominate. Despite the hatred the city has toward Brown, few can question that he's a good man. He is charitable and seems to treat his employees with a great deal of respect. Al Davis is considered by many to be unscrupulous. Watch Davis' handling of the Lane Kiffin firing and you'll see what an SOB he is. Al Davis is easily the biggest jerk amongst all the NFL owners. Advantage: Mike Brown
Commitment to the community/city: This category is a close one. Al Davis has moved the Raiders from LA to Oakland, back to LA and back to Oakland and has jerked the northern California area and fans around so many times that it's comical. Mike Brown threatened to move the team if he didn't get a new stadium. The taxpayers ponied up and built him a new stadium, a deal that favored him so much that he wouldn't even allow high school teams to play on the field or marching bands to perform at halftime (when they had grass). Brown really damaged his image as a miserly old coot when he threatened to move the team and then took advantage of the taxpayers. Advantage: Mike Brown, by a nose only because he never did move the team, while Davis did, more than once.
Long term vision/outlook: This one, again, could go either way. The Raiders have multiple owners and Al Davis is just the President and General Partner of the ownership. If he ever stepped down or died, a new owner, not related to Davis could step in with a new vision for the Raiders. The Bengals, and all of their woeful, win-craved fans, have a bleak future. If something happens to Mike Brown, his daughter Katie Blackburn would likely assume the same role her father plays. Katie and her husband Troy already play key roles in the decision making. So, the black cloud of the Brown family will hang over Cincinnati for the unforeseeable future. Advantage: Al Davis
In summary, while Davis might be a jerk and an SOB, he has proven to be a winner who knows what he's doing. His fans are passionate and still support the team. They have had their ups and downs, but they're still one of the elite franchises in the NFL. The Bengals, meanwhile, under Mike Brown's reign have done nothing except compile the second worst record in the NFL. He has never shown a commitment to win, and has only shown a commitment to sell tickets. He has never hired a GM, has never hired enough scouts and doesn't splurge when it comes time to woo free agents (including flying people in coach). In short, Mike Brown is unequivocably the worst owner in the NFL and has put a dark cloud over the city and that doesn't seem like that will ever change.